精神分裂症病人中具有宗教妄想的那些往往病情更严重 （科学论文分享）

在美一方

Religious delusions in patients admitted to hospital with schizophrenia.
Siddle R, Haddock G, Tarrier N, Faragher EB.
Department of Clinical Psychology, North Manchester General Hospital, Crumpsall, UK.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2002 Mar;37(3):130-8.

BACKGROUND: Religious delusions are clinically important because they may be associated with selfharm and poorer outcomes from treatment. They have not been extensively researched. This study sought to investigate the prevalence of religious delusions in a sample of patients admitted to hospital with schizophrenia, to describe these delusions and to compare the characteristics of the patients with religious delusions with schizophrenia patients with all other types of delusion.

METHOD: A cross-sectional investigation was carried out. The prevalence of religious delusions was assessed and comparisons were made between religiously deluded patients and a control group on demographic, symptom, functioning and religious variables. One hundred and ninety-three subjects were examined of whom 24% had religious delusions.

RESULTS: Patients with religious delusions had higher symptom scores (as measured by the PANSS), they were functioning less well (as measured by the GAF) and they were prescribed more medication than those patients with schizophrenia who had other types of delusion.

CONCLUSION: It is concluded that religious delusions are commonly found in schizophrenia and that by comparison with other patients who have schizophrenia, those patients with religious delusions appear to be more severely ill. This warrants further investigation.

PMID: 11990010 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

面瓜

也和话

回复 在美一方 的帖子

就是为什么精神科医生信神的只有很少数的一个原因。

不要忘记了颞叶癫痫在很多著名宗教人士身上发生。

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_with_epilepsy

写《旧约》的P作者们、以西结、保罗都榜上有名。

狼痞子

在美一方

回复 也和话 的帖子

还有穆罕默德。

BowBob

他们认为这是神灵与他们沟通。

sunning

也和话 发表于 2011-5-3 20:57
回复 在美一方 的帖子

就是为什么精神科医生信神的只有很少数的一个原因。

---按照你的逻辑，是不是又可以推导：精神科医生是所有职业中自杀率最高的，因为你说“精神科医生信神的只有很少数”，所以不信神的人，越有自杀的可能性？
纯属探讨哈。别又对号入座。

嘁哩喀喳

嗯，“任大”同学还听见他家主子和他说话了。

在美一方

回复 sunning 的帖子

按照你的逻辑，是不是又可以推导：精神科医生是所有职业中自杀率最高的，因为你说“精神科医生信神的只有很少数”，所以不信神的人，越有自杀的可能性？
纯属探讨哈。别又对号入座。

------------
你这个推导的逻辑好像非常难懂。能不能把大小前提和结论推导的过程说一下？

也和话

回复 在美一方 的帖子

我觉得摩西也是。

也和话

回复 sunning 的帖子

这个简单，看看自杀的精神科医生的信与不信的分布，然后再跟一般的精神科医生信与不信的分布做比较，看看有没有statistical significance。

要不，你的 statement 也只能是跟祈祷一样，以为“阿门”一下，奇迹就会发生。

不如写个 proposal，拿个 grant，一举两得。