Recovery hopes dampened by jitters
Fund managers talk like bulls, act like bears
By Steve Johnson, FTMarketWatch
Last Update: 10:28 AM ET Jun 12, 2001
LONDON (FTMW) - Fund managers are upbeat about the prospects of global recovery and corporate earnings growth.
But they still remain hesitant when it comes to their own funds, with a growing number of managers holding more cash than their benchmark levels, suggesting they are still uncertain about the markets.
The monthly survey of 270 managers commissioned by Merrill Lynch uncovered the contradiction.
A net balance of 46 percent of managers said that corporate earnings look positive (up from 21 percent in May). And 79 percent agree that equities are the best asset class.
The net balance of fund managers anticipating a recovery in the global economy in the next 12 months is up from 11 percent in May to 37 percent now.
And less than a quarter of managers predict that the economy will be weaker than now in a year's time.
Cash still king
But a net 22 percent say they are overweight in cash, 5 points higher than in May.
A cynic may argue that this is a classic example of fund managers attempting to talk up the market.
David Bowers, Merrill's chief investment strategist, who authored the report Strategically Bullish, Tactically Cautious, disagrees. "I think fund managers want this to be a textbook recovery".
"With inflation falling and monetary policy easing, they feel it is time that they ought to be investing in the equity markets, but they are worried that it might be different this time, with lopsided easing of monetary policy [in the U.S. but not the Eurozone]," he added.
"There is still a degree of tactical caution in the short term. Fund managers believe the economy will recover, but they don't know when," explained Bowers.
Risk averse
This caution is reflected by the fact that the panel of managers puts the probability of a 10 percent correction in the markets over the next three months at more than 30 percent.
"There is still a high probability of a correction in the market," Bowers added. "Managers are carrying below normal levels of risk in their portfolios."
The choice of favoured sectors is similarly schizophrenic. Energy and cyclical industrial stocks are top of the list. But managers say they are shying away from telecoms and bank stocks.
Tech and energy favoured in Europe
A separate survey of 77 Eurozone fund managers found that tech, energy and banks are the favoured sectors, a curious mixture of cyclicals and defensives. Telecoms, autos food and drink, tobacco and pharmaceuticals are out of fashion.
On a wider level, the U.S. dollar has replaced the euro as fund managers' currency of choice. The yen, and the Japanese stock market, is the one they are steering clear of.
Some 51 percent of fund managers say that the highest 'quality' of corporate earnings (in terms of volatility, predictability and visibility) can now be found in the U.S., up from 36 percent in May.
See page of funds news, commentaries and tools